My Cart 0

Premium Cigars

  • Villiger Cuellar Connecticut Kreme

    $69.50$83.00

    Villiger is synonymous with quality for well over 100 years. When this edition launched in 2018, the industry took notice. After all, this was a handmade premium. It was well received by those folks that appreciated a perfectly made, mild to mellow, smooth, balanced, cool burning stick for a more than fair price. This cigar is equally enjoyable with your morning coffee as well as an evening nightcap.

    Origin – Dominican Republic
    Filler – Dominican
    Binder – Dominican
    Wrapper Type – Ecuador Connecticut

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • Tatuaje Reserva Broadleaf

    $81.00$270.00

    We’ve often spoke about age as it pertains to tobacco. When this edition launched ten years ago, many felt it came to market before its time. While all the right components were in place, the fillers and binder were considered a bit young. With passing years, this cigar has gotten better and better. As the guts of this stick have matured and seasoned, their encasement around a Porterhouse grade of USA Grown Connecticut Shade wrapper turned the tide. In fact, this medium to full bodied stick has gotten so good they’re difficult to find most of the time. Get them when we have them.

    Origin – Nicaragua
    Filler – Nicaraguan
    Binder – Nicaraguan
    Wrapper Type – Connecticut Broadleaf

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • Tatuaje Nicaragua

    $168.75$292.50

    The carefully chosen Nicaraguan fillers and binder that are encased with a USA Grown Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper produce what some have said is an acquired taste. Although it’s medium in body, it’s also light in taste. This is a long burning stick that’s easy to handle.

    Origin – Nicaragua
    Filler – Nicaraguan
    Binder – Nicaraguan
    Wrapper Type – Connecticut Broadleaf

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • Perdomo 10th Anniversary Champagne

    $49.00$227.03

    Nick Perdomo and his Dad are well renowned cigar makers. I’ve watched them grow to one of the world’s powerhouse teams producing a wide array of highly rated premiums. In fact, over 20 years ago I remember Nick personally traveling around the country and winding up in my Long Island store soliciting for business! Many years later when I went to the last big Cigar Show trying to see him was like trying to see a rock start! His success is well earned.

    When this 10th Anniversary Champagne line was launched it was well received. Let’s face it, Perdomo only makes great cigars! The Ecuadorian Connecticut seed wrapper encasing this Nicaraguan stick yields a mild taste with a nice bit of sweetness.

    Origin – Nicaragua

    Filler – Nicaraguan

    Binder – Nicaraguan

    Wrapper Type – Ecuador Connecticut

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • Out Stock
    Ferio Tego Host Selection MaduroQuick View

    Ferio Tego Host Selection Maduro

    $27.00$191.26

    The Host Selection has served as the benchmark of mild to mellow bodied cigars over decades. The simple addition of a Broadleaf wrapper raises the needle on the flavor meter into the medium rage while remaining smooth. Many folks that enjoy its Natural counterpart like the bit of boost in taste this Maduro offers while retaining the same basic character of the Original.

    Origin – Honduras
    Filler – Honduran
    Binder – Honduran
    Wrapper Type – Connecticut Broadleaf

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • My Father Tabacos Baez Serie SF

    $15.00$66.60

    My Fathers Cigars have become major players over the last several years producing some of the most popular, highest rated entries ever. If you’re wondering how such a Super Premium company can turn out a great stick for under $3, the first answer is mixed filler tobacco.  These Nicaraguan puros won’t be around forever. They’re medium-bodied and smooth smoking with a bit of spice and………they even come in a box! Enjoy!

    Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano
    Binder: Nicaragua
    Filler: Nicaragua (70% Cuban-Seed Long Filler)

    Want to see more My Father cigars available on the Cigar Thief? Click HERE

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • Odyssey Maduro

    $34.02$52.02

    The Odyssey line is a super value priced array of everyday cigars brought to us by Premium powerhouse General Cigar. When the makers of Macanudo, Partagas and Punch…to name a few, decided to produce a well made economical smoke for everyone’s taste, they hit the mark!

    If you enjoy medium to full bodied smokes, the Maduro style has your name on it. These types of dark, oily wrappers are usually found on cigars four times as expensive!

    Origin – Nicaragua
    Filler – Nicaraguan
    Binder – Nicaraguan
    Wrapper Type – Maduro-Nicaraguan

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • CAO New Age: Flathead

    $39.57$265.46

    CAO New Age: Flathead is still one of this company’s most popular cigars, HANDS DOWN!

    CAO introduced the Flathead into the marketplace in 2015 and it received 90+ ratings immediately! This solid medium to full bodied cigar is a box pressed beauty. It’s dark oily wrapper encloses a terrific blend of fillers and binders that yield a great open draw, slow burn and robust complex taste.

    When Cigar Aficionado rated it an astounding 95, everybody took notice. Their review still stands.  “From the first light, this seriously squared-off cigar takes off with notes of ripe fruit, leather and molasses that only gain intensity as it smokes.”

    Country of Origin: Nicaragua
    Wrapper: USA Connecticut Broadleaf
    Binder: USA Connecticut Habano
    Filler: Nicaragua, Dominican Republic
    Factory: STG Danlí
    Blender: Rick Rodriguez

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    Bolivar OriginalQuick View

    Bolivar Original

    $53.00$187.00

    Bolivar Original is the Dominican edition of this famous Cuban brand coming to us from Forged Cigars within the General Cigar portfolio.

    This complexly blended Original version is a smooth smoking, medium to full bodied jewel. No surprise Cigar Aficionado bestowed it with a very respectable score of 90. Their description is perfect. “A rich brown wrapper. This cigar burns and draws well, with creamy, slightly sweet flavors. A well-made cigar.” Many smokers may also pick up subtle undertones of dried fruit and coffee as the cigar progresses, making it a dynamic and evolving smoke.

    Without a doubt, Bolivar Dominican cigars are known for their complexity and subtle power, reflecting the personality of this iconic brand. The 8 count box of 5.5 x 50 Robusto Crystal Glass Tubes are the top pick here. They also make a great gift for any cigar lover.

    See all the Bolivar Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

    Wrapper:Dominican Ligero
    Binder: USA Connecticut Broadleaf
    Filler: Dominican + Nicaraguan

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • Isla Del Sol Sungrown

    $40.00$99.58

    Isla Del Sol is another masterpiece from Drew Estate. This hand made Nicaraguan and Sumatran beauty is priced literally so everyone can enjoy them. You’ll notice a bit of sweetness when your tongue touches the cap and a hit of infused coffee/cocoa beans throughout. Depending on your taste this cigar steers toward the mild to slightly medium spectrum.

    One thing that will not disappoint is the fine construction and aromatic smoke production, the latter of which Drew Estate has definitely mastered. These totally affordable well made cigars are smartly packaged and adorned with tobacco leaves inside.

    Origin – Nicaragua
    Filler – Nicaraguan
    Binder – Nicaraguan
    Wrapper – Sun Grown Sumatra

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • Cusano 18 Double Connecticut

    $27.99$124.74

    Ok, I’m sticking my neck out here. I think this is one of the absolute best cigars you can buy for the price. Oddly enough, this edition has been flying under the radar for over 15 years. Since it’s been available, I’ve emphatically recommended it more times than I can remember. Davidoff acquired the Cusano brand many years ago and performed magic with the brand. All you need to know is that every component in these cigars has been seriously aged up to 18 years. The result of this true luxury blend is a spectacularly tasty, rich and flavorful mellow to medium flavored jewel with a great draw and a perfect burn. Try a five pack when we have them and see for yourself.

    Origin – Dominican Republic

    Filler – Dominican

    Binder – Dominican

    Wrapper Type – Connecticut Broadleaf

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View
  • VegaFina Natural

    $123.72$155.08

    The first thing I can say about this brand is that it is still one of the most underappreciated mild to mellow bodied cigars available. It’s four country blend is smooth, balanced and pleasantly tasting with a wonderful aroma from it’s large volume of smoke. They draw great and are made well to boot!

    Origin – Dominican Republic
    Filler – Colombian-Dominican-Honduran
    Binder – Honduran
    Wrapper Type – Ecuador Connecticut

    Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page Quick View